A Fragment on Mackintosh: Being strictures on some passages in the dissertation by Sir James Mackintosh, prefixed to the Encyclopaedia Britannica.

£875 · Offered by Maggs Bros Ltd

The rare first edition of James Mill’s final book, written in response to earlier critiques of his ‘Essay on Government’ by Thomas Macaulay and Sir James Mackintosh, with particular reference to Mackintosh’s famous Dissertation on the Progress of Ethical Philosophy that had been included in the 1830 seventh edition of the Encylopaedia Britannica. ‘In his reply Mill reiterates and defends the arguments advanced in his Essay on Government: all men—including rulers and representatives—are moved mainly if not exclusively by considerations of self-interest, and therefore the only security for good government is to be found in making the interests of representatives identical with those of their constituents. But, unlike the cool, detached, and ostensibly deductive Essay on Government, Mill’s reply contains a good deal of vitriol. He writes like a schoolmaster who, having lost all patience with a slow-witted pupil, is content to ridicule him before his cleverer classmates. The sight is not a pretty one, and shows James Mill at his polemical worst. Whether, or to what extent, such a splenetic rejoinder could suffice as a refutation is surely questionable’ (Stanford Encylopedia of Philosophy). John Stuart Mill would later write about his father’s work in his Autobiography, reflecting that: “His ‘Fragment on Mackintosh’ which he wrote and published about this time, although I greatly admired some parts of it, I read as a whole with more pain than pleasure; yet on reading it again, lon

Found via Rare Books Intel, a search across rare-book dealers, auction houses and marketplaces worldwide.